There are numerous ways to fund your retirement. Social Security benefits, retirement plans, savings, annuities, and stock investments are just a few of the common strategies retirees use to fund their retirement.
Two of those strategies solve the same problem from opposite ends. A reverse mortgage turns the house you already own into cash or monthly payments. An annuity turns savings you already hold into income the insurer guarantees. Both convert a large, illiquid asset into money you can spend — but what you give up, what your heirs inherit, and how firm the income guarantee is differ in ways that matter. This article explains how a reverse mortgage actually works, then puts the two side by side.
What Is a Reverse Mortgage?
A reverse mortgage works in the opposite way a traditional mortgage works. Instead of you paying the lender every month to purchase the home over time, it is a loan where the lender pays you a sum of money borrowed against the value of your primary residence. Ownership of the property stays with the borrower.
What makes a reverse mortgage appealing is that the borrower is not required to pay the funds back unless they choose to stop living in the property or decide to sell it. If the borrower passes away, the loan becomes due and the onus is on the borrower's heirs to determine how they want to handle the payment, as both ownership and the loan will usually transfer to the heirs.
To qualify, at a bare minimum, the borrower must own the home and meet a minimum age — 62 is the age usually cited for the main federally backed program. A borrower is often eligible for more money depending on what percentage of the home they actually own; if the borrower owns the home outright, they will generally get the highest amount. The borrowing limit — called the principal limit — is determined by your age, the loan's interest rate, and the value of your home, and if a spouse is a co-borrower, it is based on the younger of the two.
The borrower can take the money as a lump sum, a line of credit, or a monthly payout. If they choose the monthly payout, the retiree can essentially receive lifetime monthly income — depending on their age, how long they live, and the value of their home — similar to an annuity. That similarity is exactly why the two get compared, and it is where the fine print starts to matter.
The Annuity Side, Briefly
An annuity runs the same conversion in the other direction: you hand an insurance company a premium from savings, and the insurer commits to payments — for a set period or for as long as you live. There is no property involved, no loan balance growing against you, and no residency condition attached to the checks. The mechanics, product types, and trade-offs are covered in what an annuity is and the types of annuities, so this article won't re-explain them. What matters for the comparison: an income annuity's lifetime payout is a contractual guarantee backed by the insurer, and you can see what a given premium buys in monthly income with our current immediate annuity market.
Reverse Mortgage vs. Annuity, Side by Side
| Feature | Reverse mortgage | Income annuity |
|---|---|---|
| Asset you convert | Equity in your primary residence | Savings or investment balance paid as a premium |
| What it is | A loan against the home; the lender pays you and the balance grows with interest | An insurance contract; the insurer owes you payments in exchange for the premium |
| Income guarantee | Monthly payouts can continue for life, but only while the home remains your principal residence | Lifetime payout options are guaranteed by the insurer regardless of where you live |
| What you give up | Home equity shrinks as the loan balance and interest grow | Access to the premium; deferred contracts add surrender charges for early exits |
| Ongoing obligations | Property taxes, insurance, maintenance, utilities stay your responsibility | None — the insurer's payments arrive with no upkeep attached |
| Effect on heirs | Home passes with the loan attached; heirs typically sell or refinance to repay | Depends on payout option — life-only ends at death; refund and period-certain options pay beneficiaries |
| Costs | Appraisal, origination, servicing, and third-party closing fees, plus interest accruing monthly | No closing costs; expenses are priced into the payout rate, and optional riders carry explicit fees |
| Basic eligibility | Must own and live in the home; the main federal program requires a minimum age | No homeownership requirement; anyone with a premium to commit, subject to issue-age limits |
The single biggest difference sits in the guarantee row. A reverse mortgage's monthly payout resembles annuity income, but it is conditioned on occupancy: the home must remain your principal residence. If you move into a different home or a healthcare facility for an extended period — twelve consecutive months is the trigger the loan documents describe — the reverse mortgage may become repayable, right at the moment your expenses spike. An annuity has no such condition. For what happens to annuity payments and remaining value at death, see what happens to an annuity when you die.
Types of Reverse Mortgages
There are numerous types of reverse mortgages, but three main types you should be aware of:
- Single-purpose reverse mortgages are often the least expensive option; however, they are not available everywhere. They are generally given out for one purpose the lender specifies clearly in the contract — repairs to the home, property upgrades, or covering property taxes — and are usually offered by local or state government agencies or non-profit organizations.
- Proprietary reverse mortgages are loans offered by private companies as opposed to government agencies. Depending on the value of your home, you may get a larger loan advance with this type, and there are generally no requirements to use the funds for a specific purpose.
- Home Equity Conversion Mortgages (HECMs) are federally backed reverse mortgages insured through the Federal Housing Administration. These loans can be used for any purpose, though upfront costs with HECMs can be higher than the other options.
The FHA insurance behind a HECM matters more than it sounds. Private reverse mortgages can provide a bigger initial payday, but if the loan is not a HECM, you may end up responsible for paying the lender funds well above the actual value of the home. That protection against owing more than the home is worth is a large part of why choosing a reputable lender that offers HECMs is the standard advice.
Costs and Risks on the Reverse Mortgage Side
Reverse mortgages are not without their risks, costs, and pitfalls, and this is where the comparison with an annuity gets concrete.
- You rarely receive the full value of the loan. The closing costs for a reverse mortgage can be downright expensive: origination fees charged by the lender to complete the transaction, monthly servicing fees to maintain and monitor the loan, and third-party fees for appraisers, inspectors, and the like. An annuity has no equivalent closing bill — its costs are built into the payout rate, and you can compare contracts net of everything through our annuity calculators.
- Interest accrues against you every month. The amount you owe can grow substantially as the loan adds up over time — the mirror image of an annuity, where the insurer's obligation to you is what compounds.
- You still pay the normal expenses of the house. Utilities, fuel, maintenance, and property taxes remain yours. Not only does interest accrue every month, you also need adequate income to cover everything a homeowner normally pays — falling behind on taxes or insurance can put the loan in default.
- Moving out can end the arrangement. The home must be your principal residence — you must live there year-round, or at least the majority of the year. A permanent move, including into long-term care, can make the loan repayable.
- Not all lenders are created equal. Much like annuities, there are numerous product variations, and choosing the wrong one can cause headaches down the road. Unfortunately, there are also many scams when it comes to reverse mortgages, with lenders taking advantage of older homeowners. Seeking out a HUD-approved counselor or a real estate attorney who specializes in reverse mortgages before signing is strongly advised.
Do Not Buy an Annuity With Reverse Mortgage Proceeds
One combination deserves its own warning: taking out a reverse mortgage and using the proceeds to buy an annuity. It is a pitch some salespeople make, and it is widely criticized for good reason. You would pay the reverse mortgage's closing costs and accrue interest on the borrowed money, all to buy a contract whose monthly income may be little better — and is sometimes worse — than the monthly payout the reverse mortgage itself could have provided. The layered costs work against you from day one, and if you later need the money back, you face the annuity's surrender terms on top of a growing loan balance. If someone recommends a reverse mortgage specifically so you can buy an annuity or any other financial product, treat it as a red flag and get independent advice.
Which One Fits Your Situation?
The honest answer is that these are tools for different balance sheets, and they can coexist in one plan — funded from different assets.
- A reverse mortgage suits a homeowner who is house-rich and cash-poor, plans to stay in the home long-term, can keep up with taxes and maintenance, and is comfortable spending down the equity their heirs would otherwise inherit.
- An income annuity suits a retiree with investable savings who wants a payment the insurer guarantees for life, with no residency strings and no property upkeep attached. See which annuity pays the most for how the payout options stack up.
- Neither suits anyone being rushed. Choosing a reverse mortgage is a decision that should not be rushed, and the same discipline applies to annuities — compare multiple contracts, understand the fees, and know what your heirs receive before you sign. Our complete guide to annuities covers the annuity side of that homework.
The information here is a starting point. If you are still tempted to take the plunge on either option after reading this, please make sure you seek out further information and understand exactly what you are signing up for.
Free Comparison Report
Explore current immediate annuity options
Before borrowing against your home for monthly income, review the current immediate-annuity market and the tradeoffs involved in converting savings into guaranteed income.