Fixed Indexed Annuity
Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity
Sentinel Security Life · AM Best B
4.0/5
S&P 500 annual cap
4.1%
CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026
DB-backed product comparison
Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity vs Athene Agility 10
Decision-first comparison using current product data, carrier backing, review ratings, liquidity, surrender terms, rider mechanics, and sourced disclosures.
Live CANNEX-backed data via AdvisorWorld. Each figure below carries its source and as-of timing.
View product page
VS
Fixed Indexed Annuity
Athene Agility 10
Athene Annuity and Life Company · AM Best A+
4.5/5
S&P 500 annual cap
5.25%
CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026
Auto-verdict
Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity leads on fixed account rate, surrender period; Athene Agility 10 leads on top annual cap, carrier strength, income rider availability; liquidity and annual fee are tied. This compares current accumulation metrics and is not a personalized recommendation.
- On fixed account rate, Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity has the higher figure (3% fixed account vs 2.9% fixed account); Athene Agility 10 is lower.
- On surrender period, Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity has the lower figure (5 years surrender period vs 10 years surrender period); Athene Agility 10 is higher.
- On top annual cap, Athene Agility 10 has the higher figure (5.25% cap · S&P 500 · 1-yr point-to-point vs 4.1% cap · S&P 500 · 1-yr point-to-point); Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity is lower.
- On carrier strength, Athene Agility 10 has the higher figure (A+ AM Best vs B AM Best); Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity is lower.
- On income rider availability, Athene Agility 10 has rider data returned (1 income rider returned vs No income rider returned).
- On liquidity, both show 10%/yr free withdrawal.
- On annual fee, both show No annual fee returned.
Auto-generated from live data, accumulation metrics only, not a recommendation.
Live side by side
Compare on the numbers
Only metrics that apply to this product type are shown. Missing applicable values show unavailable.
| Metric | Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity | Athene Agility 10 |
|---|---|---|
| Top annual capAnnual point-to-point cap; S&P 500 preferred when the live strategy set includes it. | 4.1% cap · S&P 500 · 1-yr point-to-point CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 | 5.25% cap · S&P 500 · 1-yr point-to-pointLeading CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 |
| Top participation rateAnnual participation strategy; not ranked against cap rates. | unavailable CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 | 130% participation · BNP Paribas Multi Asset Diversified 5 Index · annual CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 |
| Performance triggerAnnual trigger strategy returned by the live FIA strategy feed. | unavailable CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 | unavailable CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 |
| Fixed account rateFixed account strategy when returned by the live feed. | 3% fixed accountLeading CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 | 2.9% fixed account CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 |
| AM Best ratingCarrier financial strength from the live product/rating feed when available. | B AM Best CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 | A+ AM BestLeading CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 |
| Free withdrawalAnnual free-withdrawal percentage returned in product detail. | 10%/yr free withdrawalTie CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 | 10%/yr free withdrawalTie CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 |
| Surrender periodShorter surrender period is highlighted as more flexible. | 5 years surrender periodLeading CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 | 10 years surrender period CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 |
| Annual feeHighest annual rider or strategy fee returned; lower is highlighted. | No annual fee returnedTie CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 | No annual fee returnedTie CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 |
| Income riderAvailability only; rider fit depends on payout, cost, and goals. | No income rider returned CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 | 1 income rider returnedLeading CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 |
| Minimum premiumLower minimum premium is highlighted as easier to access. | unavailable CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 | unavailable CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026 |
Scenario tool
Which one credits more in one index year?
Head-to-head crediting
Applies each product's live annual strategy rate to one hypothetical index year.
Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity
S&P 500 annual cap · 4.1% annual cap
Athene Agility 10
S&P 500 annual cap · 5.25% annual cap
At a +15% index year, the credited-interest illustration is:
Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity4.1%
Athene Agility 105.25%
Athene Agility 10 credits more here (5.25% vs 4.1%).
Assumptions: one hypothetical index year, one allocation to the displayed annual strategy for each product, and a 0% floor. Caps, trigger rates, participation rates, renewal rates, allocations, and state availability can change. This is educational only and is not a carrier-approved illustration.
Illustrative tool inputs use live product figures from CANNEX via AdvisorWorld · as of June 24, 2026.
Review-backed context
What the reviews say about each product
Linked review
Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity
4.0/5
CFA take
“In my view, the Sentinel Life Personal Choice Plus+ is a fairly niche FIA that may appeal more to investors focused on legacy planning rather than pure accumulation or retirement income optimization. The product itself is relatively simple, offering only S&P 500-linked strategies without the complexity of proprietary volatility-controlled indices. However, the growth potential appears relatively modest compared to many competing FIAs, particularly given the lower cap structures and limited indexing flexibility. That said, I find it difficult to justify several of the optional rider charges, especially since many competing annuities include features like free withdrawals, RMD flexibility, and illness waivers at no additional cost. Combined with the absence of standard nursing home and terminal illness benefits and the insurer’s comparatively lower financial strength rating, I would view this as a more specialized product rather than a broadly competitive FIA in today’s market.”
“Unbiased review of the Sentinel Life Personal Choice Plus+ Fixed Indexed Annuity, covering key features, costs, and benefits.”
Attributed to Nikhil Bhauwala.
Read the full reviewLinked review
Athene Agility 10
4.5/5
“Discover the features, rates, and riders of Athene Agility Fixed Indexed Annuity. Learn how it can benefit retirees and those approaching retirement.”
Attributed to Nikhil Bhauwala.
Read the full reviewCommon questions
Decision FAQs from the same numbers
Is Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity or Athene Agility 10 better for growth?
On top annual cap, Athene Agility 10 has the higher figure (5.25% cap · S&P 500 · 1-yr point-to-point vs 4.1% cap · S&P 500 · 1-yr point-to-point); Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity is lower. On fixed account rate, Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity has the higher figure (3% fixed account vs 2.9% fixed account); Athene Agility 10 is lower.
Is Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity or Athene Agility 10 better for income?
On income rider availability, Athene Agility 10 has rider data returned (1 income rider returned vs No income rider returned). Rider availability is only one income input; payout rates, rider fees, start age, and state availability still need review.
Is Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity or Athene Agility 10 better for liquidity?
On liquidity, both show 10%/yr free withdrawal. On surrender period, Personal Choice Plus+ Annuity has the lower figure (5 years surrender period vs 10 years surrender period); Athene Agility 10 is higher. On annual fee, both show No annual fee returned.
How to read this comparison
Compare the product job, not just one number.
Rates matter, but surrender terms, liquidity, rider mechanics, state availability, and carrier strength decide whether a product actually fits.
Rate context
Caps, participation rates, triggers, and fixed buckets show how each FIA creates accumulation potential.
Control
Free-withdrawal and surrender terms are visible because liquidity can be worth as much as a small rate difference.
Carrier backing
Guarantees are backed by the issuing insurer, so carrier ratings and product availability belong next to the rate table.
Disclosures and sources
Live product figures are sourced from CANNEX via the AdvisorWorld public API and are labeled with source and as-of timing. Product-type-specific rows are shown only when they apply; missing applicable values show unavailable and are not backfilled with stale figures.
The verdict is auto-generated from live accumulation metrics only and is not a recommendation. The crediting and guaranteed-growth tools are illustrative, use the stated assumptions, and are not projections, quotes, or carrier-approved illustrations.
Rates vary by state, premium band, and issue age. Caps and participation rates can change. Annuity guarantees are backed by the issuing carrier's claims-paying ability and are not FDIC-insured. Educational only.
Use the comparison as a starting point.
Then go back to the main rate pages to see the broader market, or run the whole-income comparison when income guarantees are the question.
Want a personalized version?
Use the public comparison freely. A personalized report is optional when you want projections based on your age, state, premium, and goals.
Optional report request