Interest Rate Rollercoaster:
What 2025 Means for Annuity Rates
As we enter 2025, the conversation around annuity rates is heating up. Following several years of rising interest rates, economists and insurers are now bracing for a potential shift—downward. The Federal Reserve, responding to decelerating inflation and early signs of economic cooling, is signaling a pause and potential rate cuts later this year. This has direct implications for the $300+ billion annuity market, particularly fixed-rate products.
Fixed-rate deferred annuities, including Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities (MYGAs), have seen explosive growth in recent years due to their attractive yields. In 2023, these products accounted for over 40% of total annuity sales, according to LIMRA. But with bond yields expected to fall, insurers may struggle to offer competitive rates in 2025 and beyond.
How Rate Changes Affect Annuity Products
When interest rates fall, insurers earn less on the fixed-income investments they use to back annuity guarantees. This results in lower crediting rates for MYGAs and smaller income guarantees for fixed indexed annuities (FIAs). Even products with market-based exposure, like FIAs, may offer reduced caps or participation rates when underlying hedging costs rise.
On the flip side, variable annuities (VAs) may become relatively more attractive in a lower-rate environment, particularly if equity markets rally on the back of rate cuts. Still, retirees who value principal protection and predictable income may find fewer appealing options if the rate drop is sharp.
Timing and Strategy Matter
For investors nearing retirement, 2025 could be a pivotal moment to lock in fixed rates before they decline further. This is particularly true for those considering MYGAs or income riders on FIAs. Rate-sensitive products are likely to lose yield as the Fed changes course.
Example:
In mid-2024, a 5-Year MYGA offering 5.2% annual interest would produce $13,000 in total interest on a $50,000 deposit. If that same product offers only 4.0% in early 2025, the return drops by $3,000 over the term.
What Advisors Should Do
Monitor Fed policy guidance and bond market trends.
Inform clients about the value of locking in yields early in a rate-cut cycle.
Use laddering strategies to reduce reinvestment risk over time.
Conclusion
With rates likely heading lower, now’s a smart time to lock in guarantees. A little planning today can lead to more peace of mind tomorrow.
Next up: How new SEC attention could reshape the fixed indexed annuity space.