Guaranteed vs Non-Guaranteed Annuity Rates


byNikhil Bhauwala

Mon Mar 11 2024

Author @ AdvisorWorld.com Inc
Guaranteed vs Non-Guaranteed Annuity Rates


Annuities serve as a favored financial instrument intended to deliver a dependable income stream throughout retirement. For annuity investors, grasping the complexities of guaranteed and variable annuity rates is essential for making well-informed choices. This article seeks to thoroughly examine these two kinds of annuity rates, highlighting their primary differences, the elements that influence them, and vital factors for investors to consider, supported by examples. Additionally, we will address other relevant subtopics to offer a concise understanding of annuity rates.

Table of Contents

Guaranteed Annuity Rates: Stability and Security

Guaranteed annuity rates (GARs) offer a predetermined rate at which the insurance company agrees to convert an investor’s pension fund into an income stream. These rates are specified in the annuity contract and remain fixed, regardless of market fluctuations.

Types of annuities offering guaranteed rates:

  • Fixed annuities
  • Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities (MYGAs)
  • Single Premium Immediate Annuities (SPIAs)
  • Deferred Income Annuities (DIAs)
  • Traditional Fixed Annuities
  • Fixed-indexed annuities (with a guaranteed minimum return)

Example: John, a 65-year-old retiree, decides to purchase a fixed annuity with a guaranteed annuity rate. He has accumulated $300,000 in retirement savings and wants to ensure a stable income stream during his retirement years. John chooses an annuity that offers a guaranteed rate of 4.5%.

With a $300,000 investment at a 4.5% guaranteed rate, John will receive an annual income of $13,500 ($300,000 * 4.5%). This fixed payment will remain constant throughout John’s life, providing him with a predictable and secure income, regardless of changes in the market or interest rates.

Even if the economy experiences a recession or interest rates decline, John’s annuity payments will remain unaffected. In this scenario, the guaranteed annuity rate shields John’s retirement income from market volatility and ensures financial stability.

The primary advantage of GARs is their predictability, ensuring a consistent income stream for the investor. They also provide protection against market volatility, offering security and peace of mind for investors who prefer stability.

Non-Guaranteed Annuity Rates: The Variable Approach

Non-guaranteed annuity rates (NGARs) are variable rates that depend on the performance of the underlying investments, subject to change over time.

Types of annuities offering non-guaranteed rates:

  • Variable annuities
  • Fixed-indexed annuities (with a potential for gains linked to a market index)

Example: Sarah, a 60-year-old investor, opts for a variable annuity with a non-guaranteed rate. She has $400,000 in retirement savings and is willing to take on more risk for potentially higher returns. Sarah’s variable annuity invests in a diverse portfolio of stocks and bonds, with its rate fluctuating based on the portfolio’s performance.

In the first year, Sarah’s variable annuity portfolio performs exceptionally well, and her annuity rate is 6%. This results in an annual income of $24,000 ($400,000 * 6%). However, in the second year, the portfolio underperforms due to market volatility, and her annuity rate drops to 3%. This reduction leads to a decreased annual income of $12,000 ($400,000 * 3%).

In the third year, the market recovers, and her annuity rate increases to 5.5%, providing Sarah with an annual income of $22,000 ($400,000 * 5.5%). As illustrated by Sarah’s example, non-guaranteed annuity rates can offer higher returns in favorable market conditions, but they are subject to market risks and may result in fluctuating income levels.

NGARs present the possibility of higher returns in favorable market conditions, granting investors the flexibility to adapt to changing interest rates and the opportunity to benefit from market growth.

Contrasting Guaranteed and Non-Guaranteed Annuity Rates: A Closer Look

To better understand the implications of choosing between guaranteed and non-guaranteed annuity rates, let’s delve deeper into their key differences and how they might impact an investor’s retirement income.

  • Guarantees and Predictability

Guaranteed annuity rates (GARs) offer a fixed rate specified in the annuity contract. This means that the income an investor receives remains constant and is not subject to market fluctuations. GARs provide a stable and predictable income stream, making them an appealing option for risk-averse investors who prioritize financial stability during retirement.

On the other hand, non-guaranteed annuity rates (NGARs) depend on the performance of the underlying investments, such as stocks, bonds, or market indices. As a result, the income derived from these annuities can fluctuate over time, potentially providing higher returns in favorable market conditions but also posing a greater risk in the event of poor market performance.

  • Risk Profile

The risk profiles of GARs and NGARs differ significantly. GARs carry lower risk due to their immunity to market fluctuations. Investors can rest assured that their retirement income will remain consistent, regardless of economic conditions.

In contrast, NGARs bear higher risk because their returns depend on market performance. Investors who opt for NGARs must be prepared for the possibility of fluctuating income levels, as poor market performance could lead to a reduction in their annuity income. However, these investors also have the opportunity to capitalize on market growth, potentially yielding higher returns than those offered by GARs.

  • Income Potential and Growth Opportunities

GARs yield a predictable income stream, which can be advantageous for investors who seek a consistent and secure retirement income. However, this stability comes at the expense of potentially higher returns that could be realized through market growth.

NGARs, while presenting a higher degree of risk, offer the potential for increased returns when the underlying investments perform well. Investors who are willing to embrace market fluctuations may benefit from the growth opportunities presented by NGARs. This higher income potential can help offset inflation and maintain the investor's purchasing power over time.

  • Investment Horizon and Retirement Timeline

The choice between GARs and NGARs can also be influenced by an investor's investment horizon and retirement timeline. Those who are nearing retirement or already retired may prioritize the stability and predictability of GARs to secure their retirement income.

However, investors with a longer investment horizon and more time until retirement may be more inclined to consider NGARs. The potential for higher returns offered by NGARs could help these investors accumulate a larger retirement nest egg, provided they are comfortable with the associated risks.

In conclusion, contrasting guaranteed and non-guaranteed annuity rates reveals distinct differences in guarantees, risk profiles, income potential, and growth opportunities. By understanding these factors and considering their unique financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment horizon, investors can make informed decisions on which annuity rate best suits their retirement planning needs.

Factors Influencing Annuity Rates

Several factors impact annuity rates:

  • Interest Rates

Prevailing interest rates significantly affect annuity rates, as insurance companies invest in bonds to generate returns. For example, if interest rates decline, insurance companies may lower the rates on newly issued annuities.

  • Life Expectancy

Longer life expectancies result in lower annuity rates since insurers must provide income for a more extended period. As advances in healthcare increase life expectancies, annuity rates may be adjusted accordingly.

  • Market Performance

The performance of underlying investments influences non-guaranteed annuity rates. A strong market performance could lead to higher NGARs, while a weak performance might result in lower rates.

  • Expenses

Administrative and management costs can impact the rates offered by insurance companies. For example, high expense ratios or fees associated with managing the annuity can lead to lower rates for investors.

Essential Considerations for Annuity Investors

Annuity investors should consider the following factors:

  • Risk Tolerance

Assess your risk tolerance to determine whether a guaranteed or non-guaranteed annuity rate aligns with your investment objectives. Conservative investors might prefer GARs, while those willing to take on more risk may opt for NGARs.

  • Diversification

Diversify your annuity investments to balance risks and returns. For example, you could allocate a portion of your retirement savings to a fixed annuity and another to a variable one.

  • Inflation Protection

Evaluate options that offer inflation protection to maintain your purchasing power in the long term. Some annuities provide a cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) feature that increases payments based on the Consumer Price Index (CPI).

  • Financial Strength of Insurer:

Research the financial strength and credit rating of the insurance company to ensure their ability to fulfill their obligations. Companies with strong credit ratings are more likely to meet their commitments to policyholders.


Grasping the distinctions between guaranteed and variable annuity rates is essential for making well-informed investment choices. By thoroughly evaluating your risk appetite, investment objectives, and financial requirements, you can choose the most suitable annuity rate for your retirement strategy. It is always wise to consult a financial professional to make sure your investment approach aligns with your specific circumstances and to receive customized guidance tailored to your needs. Equipped with this understanding, you can confidently explore the realm of annuities and safeguard your financial future.

©2024 AnnuityratesHQ. All rights reserved.